So we are trying something different now with my oldest son and his pooping in his pants issues. We have a chart with potty topics ranging from telling someone that he needs to go to actually pooping on the potty or peeing on the potty. For every deed he gets a star which translates to a treat. Our treat is gummy fruits. We have to do it for our youngest son as well since you can’t give one boy something without giving the same thing to the other. So far it’s 4-1 in favor of youngest son.